Dogs at work and the law

The link between animals and wellbeing is well established. Stroking a dog can lower stress hormones such as cortisol and help to reduce blood pressure, and employees who feel healthier and happier tend to perform better at work. That is part of the reason the question of whether dogs belong in the workplace keeps resurfacing.

Demand is growing alongside it. UK Pet Food’s latest Pet Population Survey estimates that there are now around 15.5 million dogs living in UK households, up from 12.5 million in 2021, with 41 per cent of households owning a dog. Research by pet care marketplace Rover found that 37 per cent of dog owners would turn down a job if they could not bring their dog into the office, and 47 per cent said they expected dog-friendly policies to be standard. For many businesses, welcoming dogs has become a genuine tool for attracting and keeping staff rather than a novelty.

The law has not kept pace with the trend, and there is no single rulebook for dogs at work. Instead, a business considering a dog-friendly policy has to work through property, liability, employment and equality law, each of which can stop a scheme in its tracks if it is overlooked.

The lease comes first

Where a business occupies its premises under a commercial lease, the starting point is the lease itself. Tenants should never assume that animals are permitted. Many commercial leases contain an express covenant against keeping animals on the premises, and others reach the same result through covenants against nuisance or annoyance, or through estate regulations that the lease incorporates, which are common in business parks, multi-let office buildings and shopping centres.

The wording matters. An absolute prohibition means the landlord can simply refuse. A qualified covenant, which prohibits animals without the landlord’s consent, opens the door to a request, although whether the landlord must act reasonably in responding will depend on how the clause is drafted. A tenant who brings dogs on site in breach of covenant risks a claim for damages, an injunction and, where the lease contains a forfeiture clause, potentially the loss of the lease itself.

Where the lease is restrictive, the tenant should approach the landlord. The parties may agree a formal deed of variation, which permanently alters the lease terms. Alternatively, the landlord might agree a side letter. This is personal to the tenant and can relax the relevant provisions for a limited period, subject to specific conditions being met, without changing the lease for any future assignee. If a new lease is being negotiated and dogs are part of the plan, the point should be raised at the heads of terms stage, when the tenant has the most leverage, rather than left until later.

What landlords should ask for

Landlords asked to make a building dog-friendly should think carefully about the conditions they attach. Sensible requirements include keeping dogs on leads in communal areas, proof of up-to-date vaccinations, regular flea and tick treatment, a cap on the number of dogs on site at any one time, and a rule that dogs are never left unattended. The documentation should also give the landlord the power to ban a particular dog after a breach and to withdraw permission altogether following a serious incident such as a bite.

Landlords may also want to revisit their indemnity provisions to make sure they respond to pet-related injury and damage, and consider whether a higher rent deposit is justified. They should bear in mind, too, that none of these conditions can be used to exclude an assistance dog, which is a separate matter discussed below.

Who is liable when something goes wrong

Liability for dogs is spread across several areas of law. Under the Animals Act 1971, the keeper of a dog, which will usually be the employee who owns it, can be strictly liable for damage it causes where certain conditions are met, broadly where the dog has characteristics the keeper knew about that made the damage likely or more severe. The business is not insulated by that. As occupier, it owes a common duty of care to lawful visitors under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957, and as an employer it has duties under the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 to protect employees and others affected by its activities, so far as reasonably practicable. In practice, an injured employee, customer or visiting supplier is likely to pursue the business.

There is also a criminal dimension. Under the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991, it is an offence for a dog to be dangerously out of control in any place, and since 2014 that has expressly included private property. The offence falls on the owner or person in charge of the dog, but an incident on business premises would still be serious for the business.

All of this points towards a proper risk assessment before dogs are admitted. Dogs can behave very differently in a busy, unfamiliar environment than they do at home, and the risk of a bite, a trip or a dog running loose rises accordingly. Businesses should also check with their insurers. Employers’ liability insurance is compulsory, public liability cover usually sits alongside it, and both should be checked for exclusions relating to animals. Cover for animal-related incidents typically comes at an additional premium, which can be enough to make a dog-friendly policy cost-prohibitive for some businesses.

Shifting the risk to dog owners

Many employers ask dog-owning staff to sign an indemnity, under which the owner takes responsibility for costs arising from an incident involving their dog. Some go further and amend the employee’s contract to make clear that they will be personally responsible for any damage their dog causes, whether that is a chewed laptop bag or damaged shared equipment.

Recovering those costs needs care. Under the Employment Rights Act 1996, an employer may only deduct sums from wages where the deduction is authorised by statute, by a relevant provision of the contract, or by the employee’s prior written agreement. An employer that simply docks pay after an incident, without that authority in place, risks an unlawful deductions claim.

Equality and the rest of the workforce

There is no legal obligation on an employer to allow dogs into the workplace, but there are obligations to everyone already in it. Some employees will be allergic to dogs, and a severe allergy or allergy-related asthma could, depending on its effects, amount to a disability under the Equality Act 2010, triggering the duty to make reasonable adjustments. Others will have a genuine fear of dogs. Some employers rule dogs out entirely for these reasons, while others set aside dog-free areas, designated lifts or routes, or limit dogs to certain days.

Assistance dogs sit outside all of this. Businesses that serve the public must make reasonable adjustments for disabled people, and that includes amending “no dogs” or “no pets” policies to admit assistance dogs such as guide dogs and hearing dogs. An employee who relies on an assistance dog may likewise be entitled to bring it to work as a reasonable adjustment. A decision not to allow pet dogs is no answer to either duty, and any policy should say so plainly so that managers do not apply a blanket ban by mistake.

Making it work

A business that decides to go ahead needs a written policy that reflects the realities of its own premises. It should set out any conditions imposed by the lease, which areas are off limits, whether dogs are welcome every day or only on certain days, and how a rota will work if demand is high. It should also cover where dogs can be exercised and toileted, how waste will be disposed of, and what behavioural standard a dog must meet, such as being reliably calm around strangers and other dogs with no history of aggression, together with a clear process for withdrawing permission after an incident.

Handled well, a dog-friendly workplace can be a low-cost way to boost morale and set a business apart. For landlords, it can support lettings and renewals, since few tenants want to move from a building that allows dogs to one that does not. The final decision on the premises still rests with the landlord, however, and the legal groundwork needs to be in place before the first dog walks through the door.

Karen Mason is co-founder and partner at Newmanor Law, a highly experienced commercial property lawyer, with a knack for working out the real commercial issues on any transaction and an outstanding track record of looking after her clients and getting things done.

Photo by Ayla Verschueren on Unsplash.